Monday, October 31, 2016

Gravel Bike Search

tldr I gave up on fenders and bought a Pivot Vault

There's lots of dirt roads in the front range I'd like to ride, yet nearly all the high-end bikes on the market that would be most appropriate for this type of riding were optimized for going around in circles on grass/sand, i.e. the cyclocross phenomena.
Here's what I wanted in a "gravel" bike:

  • carbon frame
  • supports 38c tire or greater
  • fender mounts
  • lower bottom bracket (ie not cyclocross specific)
  • 50/34 cranks
  • tubeless wheelset (supports > 45psi??)
  • Under 20lbs
  • Hydraulic brakes (Preferably Ultegra build)
  • No more than $4K USD
  • Internal cable routing

Here are the bikes that more or less matched the above:
  • Salsa Warbird
  • Jamis Renegade Elite
  • Norco Search
  • Felt VR (questionable tire clearance)
  • Raleigh Roker
  • Litespeed T3 (not carbon, omg expensive)

Maybe I'm a snob but I'm going to rule out most of them (Raleigh, Jamis, Norco, and not thrilled about Felt). I don't see a lot of these bikes around; actually almost never.
Some were ruled out based on the basis of no fenders, Scott Addict Gravel, and some not being carbon, Niner RLT. And BTW, I really wanted to buy a Niner again, but they can't be serious with an Aluminum frame at the carbon bike price point.
So, I ended up with a Pivot Vault. Yeah, it doesn't have fenders but I was able to get last year's model on sale, while customizing the build, and it ended up costing $1000 less than a Salsa Warbird Ultegra, and w/o a gross red/orange frame.Pivot labels the bike as a great all-arounder. It has a lower BB and shorter wheelbase, but not cyclocross specific. The tire clearance could have been better, only rated at 38c for 2016, but it has all the fundamentals in place.

No comments:

Post a Comment